• Home
  • Resources
    • Training Series
    • HDIAC Reports
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Homeland Defense Digest
    • Journals
    • Reference Documents
  • Services
    • Free Technical Inquiry
    • Core Analysis Task (CAT)
    • Subject Matter Experts (SME)
    • Featured SME Research Corner
    • Training
    • Contact HDIAC
    • Upcoming Events
  • Technical Focus Areas
    • Alternative Energy
    • Biometrics
    • CBRN Defense
    • Critical Infrastructure Protection
    • Cultural Studies
    • Homeland Defense & Security
    • Medical
    • Weapons of Mass Destruction
  • About
    • Director’s Welcome
    • About the HDIAC
    • The HDIAC Team
    • DTIC IAC Program
    • DTIC STI Program
    • DTIC R&E Gateway
    • Inquiries & CATs
    • FAQ’s
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Login / Register

HDIAC

Homeland Defense & Security Information Analysis Center

  • Resources
    • Training Series
    • HDIAC Reports
    • Webinars
    • Podcasts
    • Homeland Defense Digest
    • Journals
    • Reference Documents
    • Authors & Presenters
  • Services
    • Free Technical Inquiry
    • Core Analysis Task (CAT)
    • Subject Matter Experts (SME)
    • Featured SME Research Corner
    • Contact HDIAC
    • Upcoming Events
  • Technical Focus Areas
    • Alternative Energy
    • Biometrics
    • CBRN Defense
    • Critical Infrastructure Protection
    • Cultural Studies
    • Homeland Defense & Security
    • Medical
    • Weapons of Mass Destruction
  • About
    • Director’s Welcome
    • About the HDIAC
    • The HDIAC Team
    • DTIC IAC Program
    • DTIC STI Program
    • DTIC R&E Gateway
    • Inquiries & CATs
    • FAQ’s

Cultural Studies

Group logo of Cultural Studies
Public Group active 1 day, 23 hours ago

Understanding ideology and social, political and economic nature of other cultures and people.

  • Home
  • Forum

The Life and Death of the Human Terrain System

  • This topic has 0 replies, 1 voice, and was last updated 1 year ago by dschumann.
  • Creator
    Topic
  • 2020-01-02 at 11:40 #57753
    dschumann
    Participant

    An interesting article on the Human Terrain System in Iraq and Afghanistan.

    https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/afghanistan/2016-02-04/academics-foxholes

    I don’t agree 100% on why HTS failed, though there are many good points in the article.

    I would question the utility of “tacking on” a program to existing structures, using people who are largely unsuitable for combat service, doing questionable research, which may or may not be useful in a foreign war.

    In my experience, HTS focused too much on surveys and meaningless research without a fundamental understanding of Afghanistan and the causes of conflict there. Much like the rest of the conflict, there was very little effort spent on developing relevant research questions, and much effort in “piling on” with questions that have already been asked a million times with little/no effort to addressing the issues, analyzing cause and documenting/disseminating valuable information gained.

    Any future military cultural analysis needs to be systematic, thought out, and needs to include a robust staffing effort to ensure the right people are in the right jobs. (Personally, I think historians were grossly underrepresented in the HTS efforts in Iraq and Afghanistan, as they possess useful skills without some of the baggage Anthropologists bring with them.)

    Cultural analysis efforts need to be integrated with the (hopefully unified) Chain of Command, to ensure that unity of effort is there. “Tacking on” a team of Social Scientists of questionable provenance puts the effort at a built in disadvantage, imo.

    Research questions need to be based on the kind of passive research by people who actually understand the operational environment to ensure they are relevant. If, for instance, water supply is not an issue in that community, it does no good to ask endless questions about water supply, because the respondent will feel the pressure to respond that “yes, indeed, there are issues with the water supply” because of the pressure in many societies to please questioners.

    A Tribal Elder lies about how high the flood waters came to a HTT in Afg
    A village elder lies to a Human Terrain Team about how high the flood waters came.

    Any data gathered by cultural research needs to be analyzed by skilled people who have some kind of contextual knowledge. The current system of Military Intelligence qualified only personnel with Top Secret clearances has created an echo chamber of people without important cross-disciplinary and contextual skills. (More on this in another post)

    This post-analysis data then needs to be shared in a form that is accessed and searched easily. And, obtw, can be stored for future use as well as collated over time to expose further information through the passage of events. An institutional Wiki is ideal for this, and the DoD funded one for three years, before it withered and died do to lack of cooperation between organizations and lack of input by users.

    This is a huge subject, and I will post further on each point, in greater detail. Hopefully, this information proves to be useful, or at least controversial enough to stir discussion.

    • This topic was modified 1 year ago by jreade.
    • This topic was modified 1 year ago by dschumann. Reason: Added caption
  • Creator
    Topic

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

sidebar

Community Sidebar

Featured SME Research Corner

Dr. Timothy Endy – Infectious Disease Threats

Dr. Endy has made many contributions to HDIAC as a member of the HDIAC SME network, most recently authoring major parts of an HDIAC State of the Art Report titled, "Countermeasures Against the Degradation of Warfighter Capabilities due to Infectious Disease Threats." His research focuses on infectious disease, and he has also studied the impact they have had on U.S. forces since the late 19th century.

Read SME's Research

Featured Content

Alternative Energy: An Enabler of Military Capability

Alternative Energy: An Enabler of Military Capability

Alternative Energy is one of the HDIAC’s eight technical focus. This SOAR reviews the current state of a selection of novel, non-traditional, and/or emerging sources and technologies for harvesting, generating, and reusing energy. It offers synopses of new programs; summaries of significant technological breakthroughs and technology applications; highlights of outstanding developments; and impacts to the DoD. Read the SOAR

Operational Energy - Powering Military Operations to Achieve National Defense Strategy Objectives

HDIAC Journal Cover Volume 7 Number 1 - Operational Energy - Powering Military Operations to Achieve National Defense Strategy Objectives

Volume 7, Issue 1 of the HDIAC Journal contains article covering several of HDIAC's eight technical focus areas, to include Homeland Defense and Security, Alternative Energy, Weapons of Mass Destruction, Biometrics, and Critical Infrastructure Protection.

Read the Journal

Countermeasures Against the Degradation of Warfighter Capabilities due to Infectious Disease Threats

HDIAC Report: Countermeasures Against the Degradation of Warfighter Capabilities due to Infectious Disease Threats

This State of the Art Report explores the impact of infectious disease on military personnel, providing both an historical and ongoing risk profile of the various infectious diseases that put the warfighter at risk. It includes a look at the historical impact of infectious diseases on past conflicts before going on to detail current and future infectious disease risks, their impact on the warfighter, and challenges in prevention or treatment, and concludes with a quick-look summary of state of the art developments and recommended countermeasures to aid leaders during training and planning. Read the SOAR

Protecting Critical Infrastructure in the Digital Age

HDIAC Journal Cover Volume 6 Number 4 - Protecting Critical Infrastructure in the Digital Age

Volume 6, Issue 4 of the HDIAC Journal covers four of HDIAC's eight focus areas with articles on Critical infrastructure Protection, Biometrics, Medical, and Alternative Energy.

Read the Journal

Welcome to the HDIAC

Stephen Redifer, Director of the Homeland Defense and Security Information Analysis Center (HDIAC) welcomes you to your community of practice.

The mission of the HDIAC is to provide users with focused expert technical consulting and unbiased scientific and technical information through in-depth analysis and the creation of specialized information products in support of the HDIAC' s eight vital technical focus areas.

Read the Director's Welcome

Podcasts and Webinars

  • Critical Infrastructure Resilience – Part 2 of 2 Series: The HDIAC Podcast
  • Critical Infrastructure Resilience – Part 1 of 2 Series: The HDIAC Podcast
  • Energy Security Series: HDIAC Webinars
  • The Continued Threat of Infectious Diseases to the U.S. Military Series: HDIAC Webinars
  • Nuclear Arms Control Treaties – Part 1 of 2 Series: The HDIAC Podcast
All Podcasts All Webinars

Upcoming Events

Sun 24

TechNet Augusta (virtual events January-July 2021)

January 4 - July 30
Organizer: AFCEA
703-631-6158
Wed 27

14th Operational Energy Summit (Digital Conference)

January 27 - January 29
Organizer: Institute for Defense and Government Advancement
Thu 28

International Conference on Energy Efficiency and Alternative Energy (digital event)

January 28 - January 29
NY
United States
Organizer: World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology
Feb 02

USCENTCOM Virtual Data Symposium

February 2 - February 4
Organizer: National Conference Services, Inc.
Feb 25

15th Annual Biometrics for Government & Law Enforcement Digital Summit (100% Online)

February 25 - February 26
Organizer: Institute for Defense and Government Advancement
View all Events

Footer

HDIAC Products & Services

  • Free Technical Inquiry
  • Core Analysis Tasks (CATs)
  • Subject Matter Experts (SME)
  • Featured SME Research Corner
  • Training Series
  • Upcoming Events

About HDIAC

The HDIAC is a DoD-sponsored Center of Excellence for Scientific and Technical Information (STI) in the fields of Homeland Defense & Security, Critical Infrastructure Protection, Weapons of Mass Destruction, CBRN Defense, Biometrics, Medical, Cultural Studies, & Alternative Energy.Learn More

Contact Us

Phone: (877) 363-7422 (Toll Free)
Email: info@hdiac.org
Address: 901 N Stuart St, Suite #401
Arlington, VA 22203

Send us a Message

US Department of Defense Logo USD(R&E) Logo DTIC Logo DoD IACs Logo

Copyright 2019-2021, Quanterion Solutions Incorporated

Sitemap | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Accessibility Information
Accessibility / Section 508 | FOIA | Link Disclaimer | No Fear Act | Policy Memoranda | Privacy, Security & Copyright | Recovery Act | USA.Gov

This website uses cookies to provide our services and to improve your experience. By using this site, you consent to the use of our cookies. To read more about the use of our site, please click "Read More". Otherwise, click "Dismiss" to hide this notice. Dismiss Read More
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.